In this case study, we see an experienced facilitator working dynamically
with word families. Nancy starts with a
word family that begins with a particular consonant. Then, when she has worked
in several modalities with this
word family, she moves on to a word family that begins with the same consonant
and a vowel. And then to a
word family that begins with the same consonant and different vowel.
This case study indicates some of the advantages of working on phonics with
word families.
- Work on word families can be integrated into meaningful language
work.
Word families are lists of words. These words can be the names of group members,
familiar words from the
dictionary, words from books students are reading, words from stories that
students have written. The tutor or
facilitator can use word families to present specific phonics information
which she has identified in advance as
potentially useful, but the words that are sued to present this information
can be chosen spontaneously, from
whatever language work is going on at the time. Because the phonics work
uses words from the meaningful
language work, the phonics work always stays connected to meaningful language,
through these words.
- In word families, the basic language unit is the word, which is a recognizable,
memorable,
pronounceable unit of language.
This point about working on word families is related to the first point.
Words are meaningful, while
individual letters and speech sounds are not. because each word is meaningful
in itself, it can be recognized
in the flow of language, and remembered. Words that are important in a student’s
language and experience
will be particularly recognizable and memorable. Also, words are pronounceable
units of language, while
some individual speech sounds are not easily pronounceable in isolation.
(Try producing a “b” sound without
a following vowel.)
- Word families give learners the opportunity of discovering patterns in
the flow of speech for
themselves, in different sensory/motor modalities.
For example, in the case study, the students discovered that “Maggie”, “muscle”, “meat”,
and “microphone” all begin with the same speech sound, and that “Maggie”, “macaroni”, “mangle” and “man” all
begin with the
same two speech sounds. They discover this through listening to words that
they know, and through cursive
handwriting, which, like speech, is a sequence of connected but distinguishable
elements. Patterns of this
kind are not immediately obvious to non-readers. A number of studies have
shown that it is not easy for
adults to notice individual speech sounds in the flow of speech, unless
they are used to seeing them
represented in an alphabetic writing system. Learning phonics information
through word families is learning
new information about speech sounds and corresponding letters from old
information: familiar words.
- Word families are flexible.
Words can be grouped to emphasize any number of patterns. When a learner
is having difficulty with a
particular kind of sequence of letters or speech sounds, a word family
with that sequence of letters or speech
sounds can be created, using words that are familiar and relevant to the
learner.