Practice Exercise 8 A
Faulty Thinking
- For each sentence, state whether the statement is logical or faulty.
If it is a faulty statement, name the type of faulty thinking used and
explain why.
Example
Larry saw Greg talking to his girlfriend at noon. Greg
must have been asking his girlfriend out on a date.
Answer
Faulty thinking
Hasty Generalization - Larry has no information about the conversation
between Greg and his girlfriend.
- After talking to three doctors, reading twelve current medical reports,
and looking at electronic medical journals on the Internet, Kim decided
to eat foods with less fat.
- If that grey-haired, senile, cop could stop eating donuts long enough,
the crime rate would go down by twenty percent.
- Bert interviewed five people in his class. Eighty percent of the
people he surveyed felt that the local music station should switch to
“heavy metal” rock twenty-four hours a day. Bert concluded
that eighty percent of the people in Fredericton would listen to that
radio station if they switched to “heavy metal”.
|