Education is no guarantee of success in early labour market experiences. This finding points
to a disconnect between education credentials and the labour market which contributes to
the delay in school-to-work transitions for young Canadians.
- An increasing number of students have deviated from the linear traditional pathways of
high school/PSE to work.
Harvey Krahn and Julie Hudson, in their seven-year study of the post-secondary pathways of
Alberta’s class of 1996, found that “interrupted and non-linear (and hence longer) PSE
journeys are remarkably common” (Krahn and Hudson, 2006). This may reflect barriers to
completion for some students. But for the most part, it shows a significant number of young
people are able to reconsider their career paths and choose options to meet their career
goals. Non-linear PSE journeys and school-to-work transitions are common. Victor Thiessen,
in Policy Research Issues for Canadian Youth: School-Work Transitions, states that the
flattening of the corporate structure resulting in a decline of mid-management positions and
opportunity for promotion and the need to continually develop skills, means that youth are
less likely to follow linear career paths and that they will move from employer to school
and/or employer more often to realize career aspirations (2001).
- In Canada, there is a lack of support for youth prior to and during this transition stage.
Too many students are still selecting PSE as a default option because they do not have an
awareness of what other learning and career options exist. This may also be the reason for
an interrupted PSE path. Approximately 70% of those students who have left PSE before
completion cite that “lack of fit” issues were the main reason for leaving (Barr-Telford,
Cartwright, Prasil and Shimmons, 2003). These issues included: “not having enough interest
or motivation, not being sure what they wanted to do, wanting to change programs or that
the program was not what the youth wanted” (Barr-Telford, Cartwright, Prasil and Shimmons,
2003, 10).
The lack of support extends more significantly to those who are not PSE-bound. In Career
Development Services for Canadian Youth: Access, Adequacy and Accountability, the
authors found that youth who leave school before graduating and those making direct high
school-to-work transitions “have significantly less access to (career) services (and programs)
than in-school youth” (Bell and Bezanson, 2006).
- In Canada, career services, which are vital to preparing youth to enter the labour
market, are inconsistent, not known or rarely used.
Career services for youth to age 24, which include school-to-work programs, are not
consistent or readily accessible across Canada. They are either provincially or locally-based
programs, practices or policies which are dependent on “government policy and funding
which can leave them vulnerable to shifts in government practices” (Bell and Bezanson,
2006). Lack of consistency and visibility in transitional services and policies means that youth
tend not to be aware of the school-to-work programs that exist or are unable to access them
when needed (Taylor, 2007; Bell and Bezanson, 2006; Lehmann 2005).
In Without a Paddle: What to do About Canada’s Young Drop-outs, Patrice de Broucker
states that “[Career] counselling is an essential ingredient when young people are making
education and career choices in a highly fluid labour market environment [and] it can help
level the playing field regarding access to information for those from more disadvantaged
backgrounds” (October 2005, vi). While many of the benefits of career services are known
(see Bell and Bezanson, 2006), few students report accessing those services that are not
mandatory. Data on the number of students who access career counselling is limited to one provincial survey which reported that one-third of secondary school students accessed career
counselling. Of those who do access this counselling, most are PSE-bound (Bell and
Bezanson, 2006). And, those who have had counselling and guidance services, report being
frustrated with: the lack of connection between courses of study and career paths and the
narrow focus on university as the preferred learning option (Canadian Career Development
Foundation, 2003).