It appeared that “being different” influenced the expectations
of those people who
could have had a beneficial impact on the participants’ learning.
As one participant
said “people don’t want to put themselves in my shoes or think
about the reality of
living with a disability” (BC12). A general lack of understanding
about the
consequences of a physical disability and unchallenged myths about the
capabilities
of people with disabilities appeared to permeate the participant’s
accounts of their
learning experiences. These experiences suggest that designers and instructors
of
literacy programs involving people with disability need to engage in disability
awareness training initiatives. Such initiatives need to provide the opportunity
for
instructors to ask questions and increase their comfort level by actively
involving
learners with disabilities.
·
Negative Experience of School
Twenty (77%) participants spoke at length about their negative experiences
at
elementary and high school. These experiences focused primarily on their
perception that they did not fit into the existing education system:
“
The system caters for groups of 30-40 people, if you need
help one-to-one or you don’t fit in, you have no chance of
learning anything.” (BC1)
The participants’ perceived that rather than address the accommodations
they
needed to support their learning , the education system, particularly
the teachers,
“just wanted to push me through the system” (BC2). As a result, several
of the
participants found themselves in upper Grades with minimum ability to
read and
write, with “no F’s, A’s or B’s, nothing on my
school record but P’s” (BC1). These
participant comments reflect some of the problems:
“
After trying Grade 11 three times and failing, they got tired
of me so they put me in Grade 12 – I managed until exam
time but then panicked – couldn’t read the instructions.”
(NB2)
“
Did Grade 1 twice, didn’t pass Grade 2 but moved on to
Grade 3 and 4 anyway.” (NB6)
“
I resubmitted some assignments (cheated), but the teachers
didn’t care. Got A’s but didn’t know anything. You think
you’re getting away with it, but your screwing yourself and
don’t realize it until later.” (NB3)
Participants felt that “school made it hard
to learn” (SK1), “the
teachers didn’t know
how to help,” “felt under pressure to produce, needed more
time, slower pace, large
print books” (BC10) and “had
to repeat Grades with younger kids who would make
fun of me” (NB6). Some participants were offered assistance
in the form of scribes and tape recording as an alternative to writing
English
exams, but these well-intentioned
accommodations inserted into the regular system added another layer of
complications and meant that the participants did not actually learn
the basics of
reading and writing. |