Also, an overarching frame of reference allows to make more explicit what is
actually being measured and what is not and thus counters the risk of over-interpreting
the data and of focusing exclusively on competencies for which reliable measures currently
exist. It is important not to detract attention, and resources, for education and training
from competencies and cognitive skills that are critical in professional and everyday life,
but for which to date no adequate methodology for large-scale assessments exist.
For instance, the ALL consortium invested much in the construction of a
framework for teamwork (Baker, Horvath, Campion, Offermann, and Salas, 1999)
and the development and testing of internationally comparable measures. This effort
resulted in the recognition that measuring teamwork reliably would imply observation
of individuals interacting in teams, and thus calling for new assessment methodologies
(see Murray, 2003, p. 148-149). Thus, the fact that to date, at the international level,
it is not possible to provide reliable measures of teamwork does not mean that this key
competence is not important in different contexts. In fact, there is a broad consensus
on the importance of the ability to cooperate, or work together for common purposes,
as many of today's demands cannot be met by one individual alone, but requires
individuals to join and function in groups. DeSeCo underpins the importance of key
competencies in this domain.
7.3 ALL provides relevant information for the category of using tools
DeSeCo's findings confirm that what IALS and ALL set out to measure - prose literacy,
document literacy, numeracy, the analytic reasoning dimension of problem solving,
teamwork, information and communication technology literacy and practical intelligence
- and what was eventually reliably measured - reading literacy, numeracy, and analytical
reasoning - capture critical aspects of key competencies. DeSeCo confirms their theoretical
relevance to the category of "using tools interactively" and at the same time, places them
in a larger context.
Reading literacy and numeracy can be understood as specificities of the key
competence "the ability use language, symbols, and texts interactively" belonging to the
category "using tools interactively". DeSeCo emphasizes the need to look beyond the
technical skills
|