Assessing the Complexity of Literacy Tasks
black line image

Complexity of Process (Strategies)

Type of Information Requested

The type of information requested by a question or directive determines the kind of thinking required. Requests for ‘concrete’ information may require only observation, while requests for ‘abstract’ information usually depend on thinking processes such as generalizing or inferring. For example, it is easier to identify what a person is doing than to give the reason why they are doing it. The first request for information is concrete, asking for an action, while the second request is more abstract, asking for the person’s motivation. Cognitive processing tasks tend to be easier when the requested information is ‘concrete,’ as in persons and actions, while requests for more ‘abstract’ information, such as reasons and motivations, tend to be more difficult.

The following chart lists ratings for type of information. The ratings reflect the relative difficulty of identifying information. A rating of ‘1’ indicates that the information is highly concrete, while a rating of 5 indicates abstract information.

Rating

Type of Information

Typical Questions

1

person, animal, place (noun, not relationship), thing

Who ate the bread?
What is behind the door?

2

amounts, times, types, actions, locations, attributes (note that an attribute can qualify persons, groups, animals, places, etc., even other attributes)

What kind of dog was seen? How serious was the injury? What did he do afterward?

3

manner, goal, purpose, alternative, referent for a pronoun, predicate adjective.

How did Juan climb the wall?
What did he hope to achieve?

4

cause, effect, reason, result, similarity, explanation.

Why did the alarm sound?
What will happen if the rope breaks? What features do pensions and annuities share?

5

equivalence, difference, theme or pattern.

What are the differences between MIG and electric arc welding? In this agreement, what functions as a guarantee specification?

Previous page Table of contents Next page