An implication of considerable impact from this conclusion is that, while skill in reading decoding is necessary for accuracy and efficiency in comprehension of what is read, it is not sufficient. Limitation in reading comprehension may reflect both decoding problems and restricted oral language and conceptualizing competencies. Thus, decoding may be excellent, but if vocabulary, knowledge, and thinking processes are limited, reading comprehension (and, hence, performance contingent on such comprehension) will suffer.

To some, the foregoing statements may appear true but trite. After all, haven't reading teachers and other educators always recognized the need to teach both reading decoding and comprehension skills? The answer is yes-except that, as we have seen, reading comprehension skills do not depend as much upon reading as they do upon language and conceptualizing competency developed largely by means of oracy skills. Thus much of what is referred to as a reading comprehension problem could, just as readily, be' referred to as an auding comprehension problem. In turn, the latter process will be limited by the person's linguistic and semantic knowledge, and his ability to use that knowledge to get more knowledge from the spoken language display (ie., to conceptualize).

The fact that the distinctions being drawn here between conceptual base, oral language competency, and reading have frequently been blurred is evidenced by the following practices which, when considered in light of the developmental model, are ill-advised.

  1. Trying to teach reading in adult basic education classes in "concentrated" programs of some 100 to 200 hours. Such attempts naively fail to distinguish between teaching some decoding skills, usually confounded with also teaching new vocabulary using printed words which are not in the oracy competency of the learner, and developing knowledge structures in the student's conceptual base to which new vocabulary may be related. Since knowledge structures are achieved only over long periods of time-four years of high school are used to present college entry foundations in most specialized areas such as social studies and biological sciences-it is naive to believe that Adult Basic Education (ABE) can take a person whose language and cognitive content is almost universally found to be very restricted, and in a few hours of phonics training with some "general" reading and "general education" produce a literate adult with the language and cognitive capabilities of the typical 8th-or 12th-grade student.