|
What is really going on in such
"learning" situations must be understood as first and foremost an acquiescence
to a highly stratified, hierarchical and punitively enforced set of social
relations, relations enforced as much by classroom teachers and by parents
themselves, as by the particular male students who enact the prohibitions, the
violence and the punishments. As many women students will attest, the price of
competence is just too high, and the risks of success far too great, to permit
oneself to "master" gender-anomalous learning tasks. And this notwithstanding a
host of new policies, programs, initiatives addressing female "phobias" of new
and varied kinds. Where does this all get us?
|
It is high time we took
the weaponry into our own hands and taught each other,
guerilla fashion, its uses. |
|
It is high time we had the courage to look at how and why women
and girls are actively being prevented from developing competence, and
recognize that there has been for too many years now an active war being waged
on women. It is high time we took into our own hands the very weaponry which
has been deployed against us, and taught each other, guerilla fashion, its
uses. And it is high time we acknowledged the brutal fact that no one else will
do this for us, and explicitly acknowledged that this is because to develop
competence at all, but most especially to develop competence in relation to
high-status technologies, is to violate the unwritten law of gender. We can no
longer separate off the knowledge/skills to be learned from the social
relations which shape and constrain-and for women, severely limit-the actual
material practices of teaching and learning.
Mary Bryson teaches in the Faculty of Eduction at the
University of British Columbia, where both her department and her Dean have
tried, vigorously, to eliminate her queer presence via the "tenure process"
(unsuccessfully). She wishes she were a member of the Lesbian Avengers.
Suzanne de Castell teaches in the Faculty of Education at Simon Fraser
University. She hates writing biographical statements. She cares for one dog,
three cats, and about a hundred Japanese Koi, with Mary. This article is a
significantly abbreviated and adapted version of a chapter (forthcoming) in J.
Willinsky and J. Gaskell, (eds.) Gender In/forms Curriculum: From
Enrichment to Transformation, Teachers College Press.
- See Benston (1993) "A new technology but the same old
story," Canadian Women's Studies, 13(2),68-81; Cockburn, C. (1985)
Machinery of Dominance, London: Pluto Press; Cowan, R. (1989). More
work for Mother. London: Free Association Books; Edwards, P. (1990) "The
army and the microworld: Computers and the politics of gender identity,"
Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 16, 102-127;
Hacker, S. (1989). Pleasure, power and technology. Boston: Unwin;
Hartouni, V. (1991) "Reproductive discourses in the 1980s," in C. Penley &
A. Ross (eds.), Technoculture. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota
Press; Rothschild, J., ed. (1983) Machina Ex Dea, New York: Pergammon Press;
and Wajcman, J. (1991). Feminism confronts technology. University Park:
Pennsylvania State University Press.
- For examples, see Perry and Greber, L. (1990) "Women and
Computers: An introduction," Signs:, 16,74-101.
- Time magazine named the computer "Man of the Year."
As a past Director of Educational Marketing for Apple Computers affirmed, "The
buyers of Apple computers are 98% male. We do not feel that women represent any
great untapped audience" (cited in Sanders, J. (1985) "Making the computer
neuter," The Computing Teacher, April, p.23).
- Sutton, R. (1991). "Equity and computers in the schools: A
decade of research," Review of Educational Research, 61, 475-503.
- For comprehensive summaries of these findings, see Becker,
H. (1986). "Our national report card: Preliminary results from the new John's
Hopkin's survey," Classroom Computer Learning, 6, 30-33; Ragsdale, R.
(1988). Permissable computing in education: Values, assumptions, and
needs. New York: Praeger; Sanders, J., & Stone, A. (1986). The
neuter computer: Computers for girls and boys. New York: Neal-Schuman; and
Sutton, 1991.
|