Alberta Workforce Essential Skills (AWES) | Impact Study: Essential Skills and Food Sanitation and Hygiene Training |
Training Resources |
Effective traits |
Limitations |
---|---|---|
Resource 1 |
Includes short and clear sentences with one or two ideas; in point form; many vertical lists using bullets and enumerations; information is logically organized; good white spaces with increased margins and short lines; good format using highlighting such as bold, underline, and font style; headings used effectively; vocabulary defined in the main body of text; few negatives; good cross-references to terminology; terms are explained; thickness of manual not overwhelming. |
Format and design does not include tables, charts or graphics, no color or sidebars or tips for learning; no glossary of terms; table of contents could include more detail; no introduction that includes a brief overview to give the big picture; some of the sections could have more clearly defined the purpose; a summary review at the end of some sections are included but not for all. |
Resource 2 |
Has two levels - basic and advanced level- recognized the differing levels of learning and focus. |
|
Resource 2 |
Includes a table of contents; good introductory overview of the content, and how to use the book; each section have an informative table of contents; glossy with good use of photographs; use of color for headings; good organization of content; sentences and paragraphs are short and clear; design includes lots of headings, bold type, enumerations, bullets, different font styles, graphics, tables, flow charts, boxes and sidebars; Excellent real life pictures; each section includes a 'test yourself' practice quiz; each unit includes relevant terms with their definitions given within the concept explanation; objectives are included with each new unit; has an appendix that includes a glossary of terms, a comprehensive table of causes and prevention of food borne illnesses, information on chemical sanitizers, HACCP, and WHMIS. Format of course book is convenient. |
Although there are white spaces, the text appears dense at times; font size is small; for a basic level, it may be too comprehensive. |
Resource 2 |
Introduction to course book is thorough; has a table of contents and an index at the back; includes "Cases in Point' which engages the reader; clear objectives; includes pre and post tests to assess reader; sentences are proper length under 20 words; good end of the unit summaries; format and design includes numerous tables with gridlines, charts, bulleted vertical lists and bold face headings; good graphics; includes an appendix and a glossary of terms; the course book is very comprehensive. The small format is portable and convenient. |
Some material could use vertical lists; text dense with small font size; fewer tables and pictures in the latter half of the book. Practice test questions are only multiple choice and not other types, like short answer or true/false; a thick resource. |
Resource
2 |
User friendly; design is based on plain language guidelines. |
Need of a computer with Internet |
Resource
2 |
Short, twelve (12) minutes long; good summaries and organizers to aid retention; information is organized in steps; clear text and vertical lists to information that is textual; lots of color and graphics with demonstrations at restaurants; explanations are concise covering main components of food safety. |
Could include real life case scenarios illustrating the ramifications of food borne illnesses. |
Resource
3 |
Each section ends with a summary and review questions (multiple choice, true/false, short answer); has short and clear sentences with one or two ideas; vertical lists in point form using bullets and enumerations; information is logically organized; good white spaces with increased margins and short lines; good format using highlighting such as bold, underline, and font style; headings used effectively; good graphics, organizational charts, tables, to display concepts and cycles; good food safety self-monitoring checklist at the back of manual; vocabulary defined in the main body of text; few negatives; good cross-references to terminology; terms are explained. Convenient size. |
No glossary of terms; table of contents could include more detail; no introduction to give a brief overview and a global perspective; some of the sections could have more clearly indicated and defined purposes. |
Resource 4 |
Good introductory overview of the content and its uses; organization of the workbook clearly identifies the topics; focused on the reader; is organized and states in the 'forward' that it is written using plain language principles; each unit includes relevant terms (with a pronunciation guide) and their definitions, objectives, step by step instruction and study tips; each section concludes with a review and quiz; new vocabulary is explained; sentences are in active voice, short and clear averaging 20 words or less per sentence; use of short paragraphs; design includes vertical lists, bolding, enumerations, bullets, different font style, graphics, tables, charts, boxes and sidebars; interestingly written; includes a table of contents and a glossary of terms. Would be excellent for self-study. |
Thickness; cost |
Resource 5 |
One table in the document displays information well; formatting includes vertical lists with bullets; some procedural information is listed with step by step instructions which are clear; titles of each component in large bold print; white spaces adequate on most pages; not costly. |
No table of contents or introductory overview to give the big picture; no glossary of terms; format largely designed in column form throughout – no variation, all done in point form; no sidebars or tips for learning; no color; no clear explanations of unfamiliar terms; Small print and dense in places; table does not include gridlines; some sentences in introductory piece are long with cumbersome vocabulary; no graphics; poor quality paper. |