South Asian Women Academics in Montreal


by Nilima Mandal Giri

The existing
research
considers
women faculty
members as
one group,
hiding the
situation of
ethnic minority women.

During the second half of the twentieth century, women academics in Canadian post-secondary institutions have increased in number and also become more ethnically diverse. The existing research, however, considers women faculty members as one group, thus hiding the situation of ethnic minority women. By contrast, research on minority academics is limited and reflects the picture of the male academics (1).

This paper attempts to remedy this situation by reporting on a study of South Asian women academics in Montreal. South Asian women academics are disadvantaged in several ways: they are compelled to earn graduate degrees from Canadian universities in order to enter the academic profession here regardless of their previous educational and professional experiences and they face a number of obstacles during their education. As women, immigrants and non-whites, they have a triple disadvantage.

Immigration and Educational History
The South Asian women occupying academic positions in Montreal have entered Canada since the early 1950s. They were able to come here as a result of the liberalization of Canada's immigration policy with regard to entry qualifications. In the 1960s Canada needed more professionals.

These South Asian women wanted to study abroad because of the inherent prestige and better career opportunities resulting from a foreign degree. The majority of them arrived with their graduate student or professional husbands because conventional South Asian parents prefer that their daughters be married before leaving for another country. A few women entered Canada as unmarried students directly from India. Even fewer women entered as professionals, their husbands joining them later. Four women in my study were sponsored by a relative.

At the time of their arrival in Canada, the majority of these women were highly educated, e.g. they already had Doctoral, Masters, or Honors Bachelor degrees. Two had only high school education. Most of them also had teaching or other professional experience. Some had acquired Western educational degrees and experiences before coming to Canada. For example, two women had research experience at the University of Copenhagen, two had received Masters degrees from the University of Chicago and Harvard University, two had attended Masters programs at the University of Maryland and Washington, one received a degree from the London School of Economics and one a diploma from the University of London.

Les femmes universitaires d'Asie du Sud à Montréal
par Nilima Mandal Giri

Les recherches actuelles sur les femmes universitaires étudient le corps professoral féminin comme un seul groupe et cachent la situation des femmes appartenant à une minorité ethnique. Les recherches sur les universitaires appartenant à une minorité sont limitées et ne témoignent que de la situation des hommes. Pour remédier quelque peu à cet état de fait, j'ai entrepris une étude des femmes universitaires d'Asie du Sud à Montréal.

D'après mes recherches, ces femmes parviennent facilement à se faire accepter dans des universités canadiennes, car leur dossier scolaire et leurs connaissances en anglais sont bons. Leurs conditions de travail sont satisfaisantes et leurs rapports avec conseillers et professeurs amicaux. Toutefois, les diplômes que ces femmes avaient obtenus dans des universités d'Asie du Sud ne sont pas considérés comme étant équivalents à des diplômes nord-américains et elles doivent entreprendre des études doctorales à un niveau plus bas. Certaines ont vécu des situations déplaisantes car elles étaient immigrantes, mais selon elles il ne s'agissait ni de racisme, ni de sexisme. D'après mon étude, la situation financière des femmes mariées était sûre, mais elles mettaient plus de temps à terminer leurs études en raison de leurs responsabilités familiales. Il faut effectuer davantage de recherches sur les femmes universitaires appartenant à une minorité pour que leurs contributions et les obstacles auxquels elles se heurtent soient mieux connus.



Back Contents Next