|
Cost New technologies require a number of
investments. Educational providers must invest in communications
infrastructure, facilities and equipment, and reallocate funds and human
resources. At the personal level, expenditures must be made for equipment and
software, and many new technologies entail ongoing costs such as additional
phone lines or Internet service fees. Cost and use of resources are considered
in light of various choices and the values underlying them, particularly in the
context of reduced funding for education and human services.
The cost of new technologies has implications for quality and
access. The tendency to recover higher development costs by expanding enrolment
can mean reduced student support; selling programs to other providers can
result in a poor fit between programs and learners' needs. Unless there are
policies to maintain affordability for learners and unless educators monitor
the outcomes of using new technology, learners could face higher costs and less
accessibility than previously.
Questions Basic questions to ask include "what does
this cost" and "who is paying for it?" Further questions can explore costs in
terms of values:
- What is the purpose of this investment? To provide better
access, more successful learning outcomes (and how do we define success), or to
achieve some other goal?
- What is the value returned for the expenditure?
- How can it be demonstrated that educational technologies are
achieving the intended goals; for example that they provide better access than
the alternatives?
- How can we be assured that the costs of the new learning
technologies are "worth it", and can there be an agreed set of values to
measure this worth?
- Are the costs of new technologies justified in terms of
specific segments of the population who have previously been underserved?
- Is the investment in new technologies the best use of funds?
For example, in comparison to subsidizing child care so that women can more
readily participate in education and training?
Quality and Equality of Teaching and Learning
In this section, the quality of education is related to the process of human
growth rather than to a production system of measurable results. Feminist
pedagogy, adult education and distance education all stress the importance of
connection, including both the social interaction with other learners and
educators and the ability to link new learning to one's context, prior
knowledge and life experience.
The ability to support social learning and integration of
knowledge is an important comparison to make between new technologies and other
approaches. Technologies have the potential to promote interaction among
learners and instructors, in turn developing contact and connectedness. On the
other hand, technology-related factors can threaten the learning climate. The
sense of safety can be disrupted, technical support is often lacking, and the
essential human aspect of teaching and learning can be overshadowed by an
emphasis on perceived economies.
The direct experience of learners, instructors and facilitators
in using new learning technologies is an important touchstone in exploring
issues of quality and equality of learning.
Questions Questions to ask about the quality and
equality of learning are:
- Is the new technology appropriate for the learning task at
hand?
- Does this technology broaden, rather than narrow, the kinds
of teaching and learning approaches that can be used?
- Does it support individual learning, by permitting
self-pacing, ready access, learner control?
- Does it support social learning, by enabling consultation,
peer learning, mentoring?
- Is the technology transferable so that it is useful not just
in the specific learning context but in other learning contexts, at work and at
home?
- What advantages does it offer over other methods, for
example, classroom learning or other technologies?
|