Plain Language Association
International (PLAIN) Fourth Biennial Conference Proceedings |
|
Toronto, Canada September 26 - 29, 2002 | |
Click here to link to the Plain Language Association International (PLAIN) website |
These proceedings are copyrighted by
their authors and published here with permission. Please contact the author directly for permission to reproduce any of this material. |
Session Topic | Presentation Title | Speaker | ||
Opening Plenary | Plain Language: The international
pilgrimage Religion has nothing to do with plain language, right? Christine masterminded the Steering Committee's surprise entrance to the PLAIN 2002 conference in pilgrim garb. We often forget the international sweep of our movement. Christine's opening speech was an around-the-world and across-disciplines voyage to explore the heart of plain language. |
Christine Mowat |
||
A Brief History of Plain Language Although we often think of George Orwell's classic essay on the politics of language as the starting place for the plain language movement, we are part of a tradition of advocacy for grace, simplicity, and equity in communication that goes back to Chaucer and beyond him, to the hybrid beginnings of the English language. Sally's short historical tour honoured the work of the plain language pioneers in our midst. |
Sally McBeth |
|||
On the "Bridge" and in the "White Space": What to do between sessions Michelle told delegates about the conference activities she had organized around the concepts of bridges and white space. Bridges are structures that help people and things connect. On the bridge or walkway area of the hotel, we brought the work of our international community together in displays of plain language resources and examples. Document designers often promote blank or white space to give readers' eyes a place to rest between text and graphics. Our conference "white space" was the informal, unstructured places where we relaxed and consolidated the knowledge gained during the scheduled program. NEW! CBC Radio transcript On October 1, 2002, as a follow-up to the PLAIN 4th Biennial Conference, Co-chair Michelle Black appeared on CBC Radio One's Ontario Today Phone-in with host David Stephens. The question for callers was, "Who do you think needs a lesson in plain language?" This transcript appears with the permission of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. |
Michelle Black |
|||
F1 The global village: International language & communication standards for the Web |
Plain Language in the Global Village The rules of plain language, says Stephen, may have been written only for a domestic audience. In this talk, he demonstrated how and why the style must be modified when editing for international or multicultural markets. One culture's plainness, for example, may be another culture's rudeness. |
Stephen Roney |
||
The Plain Web The Web is a vast library filled with writing that is often as far from plain language as it is possible to get. Chuck's talk focussed on the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines that relate to plain language. Governments and commercial organizations around the world are adopting W3C standards as law or policy. Chuck hopes to get more plain language professionals involved in the work of the W3C. |
Chuck Letourneau |
|||
F2 Literacy & plain language in Canada: New data, tools, and strategies at the federal level |
Literacy
and Plain Language in Canada: New data, tools, and strategies at the
federal level
|
|
||
Assessing the Complexity of Literacy
Tasks Michel presented a new tool called "Assessing the Complexity of Literacy Tasks." It is designed to help document designers understand the ability levels of readers as defined in the International Adult Literacy Survey. This complexity-rating tool, based on the work of Irwin Kirsh and Peter Mosenthal, can help information designers ensure that the level of complexity of public information matches the literacy level of the target readers. It complements plain language techniques and can deal with some of the shortfalls of readability formulas based on school grade levels. |
Michel Gauthier |
|||
F3 Plain language in the new European Union |
Plain Language in Sweden: a Progress
Report Bengt and Maria talked about the successful European Law Conference held during Sweden's presidency of the Union and their attempts to move the European Union away from a traditional, bureaucratic way of writing legislation. They also described a new tool developed by a linguist to evaluate the comprehensibility of communications from the Swedish public authorities. They presented the results of that evaluation and of other projects. |
Bengt Baedecke Maria Sundin |
||
F4 The progress of plain language in the United States: A federal perspective and new research on plain language judgements |
The
Progress of Plain Language in the US: A federal perspective
|
Joseph Kimble |
||
The Progress of Plain Language in the US: A federal
perspective Joanne reported on progress made since PLAIN's Houston Conference by the agencies that are still active members of the U.S. Plain English Network. She commented on what the change in the Administration has meant and described recent projects in the FDA as well as the Department of Health and Human Services. Joanne also looked at how the events following September 11 underscored the importance of clear communication in public health. |
Joanne Locke |
|||
F5 Did a Butterfly Elect George Bush? The implications of design on voter literacy |
Did a
Butterfly Elect George Bush? The Implications of Design on Voter
Literacy
|
Greg Ioannou |
||
F6 Health: How plain language makes a difference |
Health:
How Plain Language Makes a Difference
|
Helen Osborne |
||
The Road to Recovery Project Carolyn described a project called Home Care after a Heart Attack, for which her company was asked to design some forms. What evolved was something much more than a few forms. She shared the story of how the project won Best of Show in a Society for Technical Communication competition. |
Carolyn Watt |
|||
F7 Business and finance: Progress at the British Columbia Securities Commission and the Office of the Auditor General of Alberta |
Plain Language: A case study at the British Columbia Securities
Commission Joyce and the British Columbia Securities Commission firmly believe that securities regulations should be clear and understandable to all investors, regardless of their sophistication, as soon as possible. She described their ambitious program to train 200 staff in the principles and practice of plain language. They did not stop there, however. While BCSC's jurisdiction is provincial, its capital markets are essentially national. Joyce and her colleague Michael Bernard have worked tirelessly with other provinces and with the Canadian Securities Association to promote harmonization. |
Joyce Maykut |
||
A Plain Plan In the fall of 2002, Merwan Saher and his team launched a project to further improve their annual report. He will describe how they got the needed support from management, ensured that auditors retained control of their writing, and provided needed resources. Changing the way you communicate, says Merwan, will change the way you do your work". |
Merwan Saher |
|||
F8 The Law: Why change time-honoured practices? A debate |
The Assumptions Behind Plain Legal
Language In a panel discussion chaired by Joseph Kimble, Brian Hunt and Peter Butt argued the assumptions behind the use of plain legal language. Brian posed the questions: Is there really a demand for plain language legislation? Would plain language legislation function as intended? Peter presented evidence from recent research supporting the claim that plain language benefits legal documents and statutes. |
Peter Butt |
||
Plain Language in Legislative Drafting: An Achievable Objective
or a Laudable Ideal? In a panel discussion chaired by Joseph Kimble, Brian Hunt and Peter Butt argued the assumptions behind the use of plain legal language. Brian posed the questions: Is there really a demand for plain language legislation? Would plain language legislation function as intended? Peter presented evidence from recent research supporting the claim that plain language benefits legal documents and statutes. |
Brian Hunt |
|||
F9 The global village: Getting the message across in languages other than English |
The
Global Village: Getting the message across in languages other than English:
The Canadian example
|
|
||
Getting the Message Across in Languages Other than English: The
Canadian example This session is of special interest to plain language professionals who are increasingly asked about issues of clarity in translation. Do the syntax and vocabulary of romance languages require techniques different from those used in English to achieve clarity? What are the differences, and what principles hold true across languages? |
Nicole Fernbach |
|||
F10 Health: Models for developing plain language materials and for training health care providers in these skills |
Hey, I can read that! Perspectives on plain language and people
with developmental disabilities Jean talked about how teams of people with developmental disabilities create plain documents. She described how they do it and how this work has changed her as a person. Janet discussed some of the problems of producing materials for people who have more difficulty reading and understanding. She gave suggestions based on experience and talked about the effects of the plain language movement on the rehabilitation profession. |
Janet Pringle Jean Ross |
||
Training Health Care Providers in Plain
Language Health care practitioners are increasingly aware of the need for easier-to-read, plain language materials for patients and their families. If people working in health care are responsible for choosing and developing appropriate print materials, they need to learn some new skills. Audrey described the evolution of an in-depth, "institute" model that has been used to successfully train more than 75 health care providers a year for the last 11 years, in two U.S. locations. |
Audrey Riffenburgh |
|||
F11 The law: New language and a new look for Canadian legislation |
Enacting Legislation? How About Communicating It
Too? Traditionally, a statute is a message of the sovereign to the people (at least in Canada!). The accent is not on communicating the information it contains. Philippe described a prototype project of Justice Canada to develop a more accessible act. If this prototype is approved by Parliament, all federal legislation in Canada would be drafted using some or all of the features developed for the Employment Insurance Act. Philippe presented those features at this session and talked about the evolution of a new writing culture for legal drafters. |
|
||
F12 Business and finance: Case studies in problem-solving and improved performance |
Plain Language as Problem-Solver A training and consulting project with a recently merged accountancy firm in New Zealand provided Jacquie with some interesting insights into the increasing relevance of plain language to intensely competitive commercial environments. She worked with people from a range of levels within the firm to redesign the monthly reports they made to their clients. Plain language consultants will appreciate the main lesson of this project: the support of those at the top of the organisation is essential. |
Jacquie Harrison |
||
Business
and Finance: Case studies in problem solving and improved
performance
|
|
|||
Keynote address | Doublespeak in Corporate Communications
|
William Lutz |
||
S1 The Global Village: Clear, cross-cultural communication |
The
Global Village: Clear, cross-cultural communication
|
|
||
S2 Health: Effective verbal and online communication |
Health:
Effective verbal and online communication
|
|
||
Nutrition Educators Learn Plain Language Basics: On-Line, Quick
and Easy Nutrition educators who choose and develop print materials need to learn plain language skills. However, distance, budgets, and time can limit attendance at trainings. To address these challenges, nutrition educators with the Oregon State University Extension Service developed Web-based information modules. Ellen described this exciting project and the positive reaction it has received from users. |
Ellen Schuster |
|||
S3 The law: Practical issues in legal drafting |
A Dainty Dish to Set before the King: Plain Language and
Legislation One of the seminal points in the development of plain statutory language is the change from the imperative "shall" to "must." Although apparently small, this has proved to be a key marker of the adoption of plain language legislation. Nick discussed how this shift helps us understand what is different about the way legislative language functions, and argued that such an understanding is necessary if drafters are to continue to pursue effectiveness and clarity. |
Nick Horn |
||
The Triangle Triage Technique: Polishing the
Document Professor Lantzy presented a workshop in the Triage Technique for perfecting legal documents. This technique breaks down the process of document development into separate, ordered stages. She used legal materials to illustrate common problems and explain how this approach helps the writer to solve them. |
|
|||
S4 Case studies: Changing the writing culture in a large financial institution and a large public health department |
Clear Language and Organizational Change The goal of Public Health is to promote and protect health and prevent disease. Jamie explained how, at Halton, clear language is one component of a larger "Equal Access Strategy" that aims to remove barriers to public health services. Participants who attended this presentation learned about the energy needed to champion a clear language strategy in a dynamic, multidisciplinary environment; and the rewards that accrue to an organization embracing change. |
|
||
Plain
Language at American Express
|
Ian Cooper |
|||
S5 Plain Language and Worker Leadership |
Plain Language & Worker Leadership: The Canadian
Labour Congress Takes on the Challenge The Canadian labour movement spends a great deal of time and money on communications with its 3.5 million members, who are spread across Canada in a vast range of jobs and with a wide variety of education and language backgrounds. Messages about workers' rights, social justice, and solidarity do not always have the impact intended. Barbara and Tamara's presentation looked at how the Canadian Labour Congress has taken significant steps to raise the issue of clear language within the Canadian labour movement. |
Tamara Levine |
||
S6 What's New With Grammar, Style, and Usage in the Digital Age? A practical, interactive session with a master editor and author |
What's New
With Grammar, Style, and Usage in the Digital Age? A practical, interactive
session with a master editor and author
|
|
||
S7 The "Why and How" of Plain Language: An introduction and news from the British Plain English Campaign |
Plain English Campaign, UK George and John talked about language and empowerment - giving consumers the information they need to run their lives effectively and safely. They gave examples of baffling communication, and explained why people use complicated language. They discussed some of the myths that surround the term "plain language" and showed how the techniques go beyond just crafting the words. Finally, they used case studies to illustrate the benefits of plain language - efficiency, profitability, precision, and consumer satisfaction. |
George Maher John Wild |
||
S8 Designing a Business Communications Course at WITS University, South Africa |
Business communication for accountants at
Wits South Africa has 27 spoken and 11 official languages, and no uniform level of proficiency in English. Yet education, access to information and transparency are basic human rights, according to the new constitution. Plain language therefore plays a vital role in attaining these goals. Because plain language skills are also necessary for successful participation in the business community, the School of Accountancy at the University of the Witwatersrand developed a Business Communications course. Deirdre described the rationale for and design of the course, with a focus on the centrality of plain language. |
Deirdre Viviers |
||
International Plenary Panel Plain language progress around the world |
Plain Language Progress Around the
World Conference delegates, from the Plain Language Association International (PLAIN) Fourth Biennial Conference, gathered after lunch on Saturday in the Main Ballroom to hear a panel of colleagues report the challenges and prospects for change they see in the nine nations where they do their plain language work. |
|||
S9 The global village: International business and technical communication |
English in Intercultural Business: The Issue of
Slang Sana examined the impact of slang on international business communication, offering examples of current business slang and possible misinterpretations. Her presentation included a historical perspective and a discussion of how slang terms arise, and provided techniques to decipher many current slang expressions. |
Sana Reynolds |
||
AECMA Simplified English Poppy gave a brief history of how and why Simplified English (SE) was developed, and an overview of the SE rules for vocabulary and grammatical style. A before-and-after analysis of cautions and warnings showed the benefits of SE to an industry in which quick and clear understanding of maintenance procedures is a vital safety consideration. |
|
|||
S10 Using readability tools |
Using Readability Tools With the growing popularity of readability formulas, it is important to appreciate what they are good for and not good for. Handled properly, they can produce marvellous results. Not handled properly, they can actually reduce comprehension. Like other forms of testing, the formulas find problems. Finding solutions requires a writer's skill. Bill introduced participants to a number of tools and outlined the key principles and techniques that lead to their proper use. |
|
||
S11 Case studies: Strategies for changing the writing culture in legal and insurance companies |
How Dolly Cruikshank Changed the Writing Culture of a Law
Firm Tim has applied his creative writing experience to his position as a precedents manager. He described how his use of humour and fictional characters in his regular newsletters have made the firm's writing culture less pompous and more conscious of good writing. |
Tim Miles |
||
S12 "So, what do you do for a living?" Advice from an expert on marketing your plain language services |
Creating a 30-second commercial: How to "grab 'm & sell
'm" If you attend breakfast meetings, luncheons, trade shows, or social gatherings, you need to have a ready-made answer to the question "What do you do?" For plain language professionals, it's not always easy to come up with a snappy answer. At the end of this interactive workshop, participants could develop a 30-second commercial that clearly described what their company does and how their products or services can benefit customers. |
Danna Yuhas |
||
Closing Plenary | Plain Language: beyond a 'movement' No longer a movement. More than a compliance issue. Plain language is essential for excellent customer and client service. And it's a distinguishing feature that customers and clients value. Plain language has evolved to become a product, or a business, or an industry. This development promises benefits for all: greater access to justice, improved efficiency and effectiveness, and increased respect for the rule of law. Now that plain language has come of age, we need to see it afresh. How? In this closing address, Christopher suggested some fascinating answers to that question, to help to send us home with renewed purpose. |
Christopher Balmford |
||
POSTINGS | Postings in the "White Space": Before/after documents from
delegates and suggested resources
|